In:

Why It’s Important to Consider a Substitute Decision Maker for an Incapable Adult

This month’s blog post was written by Jordana Talsky, lawyer and founder at C’est la Vie Estate Law.

In Ontario, managing the care and finances of an adult who is incapable of making decisions is a serious legal and practical responsibility. Many families step in informally, paying bills, arranging care, or managing property without any legal authority. While this may seem sufficient, it can lead to complications. 

Understanding Incapacity: Ontario Law

Generally speaking, Ontario’s Substitute Decisions Act, 1992 (SDA)[1], provides the criteria for determining whether an adult is capable of making decisions about their property or personal care matters. This typically involves assessing whether the individual:

  1. Understands the information relevant to the type of decision; and
  2. Appreciates the reasonably foreseeable consequences of a decision or lack thereof.

It is important to recognize that a person may be capable of making some kinds of decisions but not others — for instance, capable of deciding where to live but not of managing investments. This ability to understand and appreciate relevant information can also fluctuate over time due to health, medication, or environmental factors. 

When a person is incapable of making their own decisions, they need a substitute decision maker to plan or carry out decisions on their behalf. Without a formal substitute decision maker in place, there could be delays and issues in handling the incapable’s personal and financial matters. 

For example, if a parent dies leaving part or all of their estate to an incapable adult child, the surviving parent may assume they can informally handle the incapable adult child’s inheritance or care decisions. However, financial institutions cannot release funds to anyone without legal authority – not even to a parent or a spouse. Legal authority must come from a court guardianship order, a statutory guardianship through the Office of the Public Guardian and Trustee (PGT), or an existing power of attorney (POA) executed by the adult child when they were capable.

Further, the estate trustee of the deceased parent’s estate must hold back the incapable beneficiary’s share until a guardian or attorney for property is in place. Without one, estate administration can stall, delaying the final distribution of the estate. If the delay continues, the PGT may be notified to protect the incapable beneficiary’s interest by taking control of the funds until a private guardian is appointed. These delays can be lengthy and costly but are avoidable with proper planning.

You could also expose yourself to liability by informally managing an incapable adult’s finances — such as through joint accounts or signing documents on the person’s behalf.

Additionally, if a person is incapable of making health or personal care decisions and has no POA, Ontario’s Health Care Consent Act, 1996[2], lets certain relatives—such as a spouse, partner, child, parent, or sibling—make health decisions, but only in limited situations. The law covers consent for medical treatment, admission to care facilities, and personal assistance services. It does not authorize decisions about housing, safety, or other daily personal matters. If those kinds of decisions are needed, someone may have to apply to the court to become the person’s guardian.

Planning to Protect an Incapable Adult

A capacity assessment is often the first step in determining what legal action is needed if you suspect an adult may be incapable of making decisions. In Ontario, only a designated Capacity Assessor, qualified under the SDA, can determine if a person is capable of making property or personal care decisions.

A formal capacity assessment should consider if the individual:

  • can manage their property; 
  • can manage their personal care; and 
  • is capable of executing a POA to appoint a substitute decision.

If the person has sufficient capacity to grant a POA, it avoids the need for court involvement and allows the individual to choose who will act for them should they lose capacity. Ontario recognizes two types of powers of attorney:

  • Power of Attorney for Property, which governs decisions relating to the person’s property (e.g., house, investments, bank accounts, etc.). A power of attorney for property can, for example:
    • be “continuing”, meaning that it is in effect from the day it is executed and continues to be in effect even after the grantor of the POA becomes incapable; or
    • come into effect upon a certain date or event (like incapacity). 
  • Power of Attorney for Personal Care, which covers health/medical, safety, hygiene, clothing, nutrition, and shelter decisions. 

However, if a person is incapable of executing a power of attorney for property and/or personal care, guardianship is the only solution to appointing a substitute decision maker. In such cases, a formal proceeding is needed through the courts to appoint a guardian to handle the incapable’s property and personal care matters. A formal capacity assessment by a designated capacity assessor is needed in support of the court application. A guardianship application can be costly and can take months, or even years if the matter is contentious.

Moving Forward: Practical Steps

To ensure capable management and avoid future complications, families should:

  1. Consult a lawyer experienced in capacity and estate law to identify the best legal pathway.
  2. Obtain a capacity assessment from a qualified professional to confirm whether the person is incapable and in which areas.
  3. Depending on the outcome of the capacity assessment, determine if a guardianship order is required or if the individual can execute powers of attorney for property and/or personal care.
  4. Keep financial and legal affairs current, including insurance, tax filings, and property maintenance, to protect the incapable person’s assets while legal processes unfold.
  5. Include incapacity plans in your own estate planning to ensure someone you trust will manage your affairs should you lose capacity.
  6. Name trusted decision-makers to manage any funds left in trust for an incapable loved one. 

Why Acting Now Matters

Families often manage an incapable adult’s care out of love and necessity, but informal arrangements are not a substitute for legal authority. Without guardianship or a valid POA, essential matters — such as releasing an inheritance, selling property, managing joint accounts, or personal care concerns — can be delayed or blocked entirely. These issues are further exacerbated if a parent of an incapable adult child dies without any formal arrangements in place.

A capacity assessment is often the best starting point. It clarifies whether guardianship is required or whether a POA remains an option. Taking formal steps now ensures that decisions can be made lawfully, finances remain protected, and the incapable person’s well-being is secured.

Ultimately, acting before a crisis arises creates stability, transparency, and peace of mind — protecting both the incapable person and those who care for them.

[1] SO 1992, c 30.

[2] SO 1996, c 2, Sched A.

DISCLAIMER

Terms of Use

By accessing the Wealth Matters – Our Insights page, you agree that you have read, understood and agree to be bound by the website terms of use, in addition to the terms stated below.  If you do not agree with this website’s terms of use, please exit from this page, and do not access any other pages on this website.

Cidel Bank & Trust Inc. (including its subsidiaries and affiliates, “Cidel”) reserves the right, at its discretion, to change, modify, add, or remove portions of this page, and the information contained herein, without prior notice. 

 Information Is Not Legal or other Advice

 Wealth Matters – Ours Insights publications are intended to convey general information about legal issues and developments as of the indicated date.  It does not constitute legal, tax, accounting, or any other advice and must not be treated or relied upon as such.

Statements made in Wealth Matters – Our Insights publications, including the interpretation of case law, are of a general nature only and in no way represent a warranty of the position or accuracy of the law at the time, nor do they pre-determine any position Cidel may take with respect to a specific fact situation or particular client matter. Furthermore, Cidel does not endorse, guarantee the accuracy of, or accept any responsibility for any content written or contributed by third parties who are featured as guest bloggers on Wealth Matters – Our Insights, nor does Cidel endorse, guarantee the accuracy of, or accept any responsibility for the content of third-party websites or materials that may be linked, quoted or otherwise referenced in these publications.  For greater certainty, Cidel does not warrant or guarantee that the information contained on this page is accurate, complete, updated regularly and obtained from reliable sources.

In making the Wealth Matters – Our Insights page available, no client, advisory, fiduciary or professional relationship, including a client-solicitor relationship is created, intended or established. The contents are not a substitute for the user seeking advice from a professional that is familiar with the reader’s factual situation or circumstances.